Sprott Money Contact Form

Thank you for contacting Sprott Money.  We will respond to you within 1 business day.



The Sprott Money Team

Sprott Money Ltd.
111 Queen St. East
Suite 501
Toronto, Ontario M5C 1S2

[t] 1.888.861.0775
[f] 416.861.9855

Administrative office only - no walk-in sales.


Please Try Again After Some Time...
Please enter valid captcha
Loading Image
Click here for an Important Message for Customers

Important Message For Customers:

The Ontario Government has legislated that all non-essential businesses MUST BE closed BY 12:01 am on March 25. The health and safety of our employees, clients and our community is our top priority. To do our part in slowing the spread of COVID-19, our staff are working remotely until further notice.

Furthermore, our carrier, UPS, has notified us that all shipments will not be insured and will not require a client’s signature upon delivery until further notice. Given the nature of our business, we are not willing to take that risk with your investments. As a result, we are temporarily suspending all shipments within Canada until UPS lifts these protocols.

Use e-mail for more expedient service.

Please be assured that your orders will be shipped to you as soon as we can. These are valuable investments you are making, and we want to make sure we send them in a safe, secured and insured manner. Should you have any questions or concerns, please reach out to us at 1-888-861-0775 or email us at sales@sprottmoney.com

Thanks for your patience and understanding in this difficult time.

Swipe to the left

Pirates, Arbitrage, and the Silver Flash Crash - Viking Analytics (7/7/2017)

Pirates, Arbitrage, and the Silver Flash Crash - Viking Analytics (7/7/2017)
By Viking Analytics 3 years ago 25652 Views 1 comment

July 7, 2017

One of the quotes that guides my investment and trading philosophy is attributed to Benjamin Graham:

In the short run, the market is a voting machine. In the long run, it is a weighing machine.

- Benjamin Graham

With this quote in mind, I look for occasions when commodities and stocks have diverged from fundamental value, and seek to profit from that divergence. Often, the divergences can last longer than anyone might expect. But, that is a topic for another article.

In this article, I want to look at this quote in a specific and practical way, and apply it directly to the recent "flash crashes" that we have seen in tech stocks, gold, and now silver.

Graham says, "in the short run, the market is a voting machine." Here is the one of the problems with that true statement: there are entities who have the ability to stuff the ballot box and profit from nano-second moves in the markets. At certain times of limited liquidity (or otherwise), the market "voting machine" can easily become an "arbitrage machine."

Silver Flash Crash

As has been widely reported, the COMEX silver market (owned and operated by CME Group) "flash crashed" from a high of $16.07 to a low of $14.34 before recovering to close at $15.90 over a 5 minute trading block of 8,000 contracts. This many contracts amounts to 40 million notional ounces of silver, 4.4% of annual mine supply traded in 5 minutes!

Source: TradingView

Peter Pan Becomes a Pirate

One of my favorite quotes from film comes in one of the modern renditions of Peter Pan in the movie Hook. Peter Pan (played by Robin Williams) has left Never-land, and has become a swashbuckling investment banker. Wendy goes to Peter Pan to let him know that he is needed in Never-land. Upon hearing about Peter Pan's new job, Wendy is astonished to see that the boy hero Peter Pan is now playing the part of a real-life pirate.

While I have not become a pirate, I have found that it can be occasionally profitable to think like one. In a game theory analysis of the commodity markets, I try to think like a pirate would think.

If I Were A Pirate . . .

Before we get to our pirate flash crash strategy, let's look at a recent bid-offer stack for the iShares Silver Trust ( SLV). In this example, there are almost 400,000 bids to buy SLV at 14.91, and almost 110,000 offers to sell SLV at 14.92. Most retail investors have the ability to see this bid-offer stack, and the same kind of bid-offer stack exists in the futures markets in addition to the stock markets.

Source: E-trade

If I were a pirate (I am not), having the means to do so (I don't), I would evaluate the bid-offer stack of my target commodity, and during times of illiquidity (like 4am EST on a Monday, or 7pm EST on a Thursday), I would set up limit purchase orders 10% below the current price (for example), and then place a sell order that hits every bid in the bid stack (and triggers known and unknown stop loss orders at key technical levels).

The cascading effect of the flash sale, combined with the known and unknown stop loss sale orders (designed to protect long positions and/or profit from a new downtrend) might cause price to decline to the place that I had established my purchase orders.

All of this can be optimized by HFT algorithmic computers that have a form of market price omniscience, being fed with the bids and offer data, and oftentimes the stop loss data as well.

Five minutes later, price recovers almost to where it was before, and I would have arbitraged the bid-offer stack.

Who Loses In This Flash Crash?

The person who loses in this flash crash is the retail and other investors who do not have the same level of information and market-moving ability as others, and have attempted to protect their long positions with stop-loss orders.

Here are a couple of tweets from this morning that elaborate on that point. First of all, I am impressed that CME Group responded quickly to adjust and correct some of the orders during the flash crash period.

One trader reported that he had established a protective stop loss order at $15.80/oz. Nevertheless, stop loss orders are sometimes only triggered if there is an actual bid or offer at the level of the stop loss order. In this case, the trader first had an effective stop loss at $15/oz before it was corrected to $15.56/oz by CME Group.

Either way, the retail investor got fleeced by a 5 minute up-down spike in the price of silver. After the dust had settled, and if this trader had not had the protective stop order of $15.80, he would have still had his long contract at a value of $15.90.


We have attempted to alert readers to this kind of activity before, but it is of course complex and takes some contemplation to follow along. This example above is a more detailed example of what I attempted to explain in one of my prior articles: Trading JNUG and NUGT? Play Blackjack Instead .

Because of this kind of activity stop-running activity can occur in all markets, we try to focus on the end-of-day closing price and set mental stops, not actual stop loss orders for our swing trading holdings. Unfortunately, some or most of the stop loss order information is sold as information to firms with the ability to profit from that information.

I continue to try and think like a pirate to get a sense for where the markets might be arbitraged next. I have developed some interesting tools and information that I share with my Seeking Alpha subscribers, such as the option market price magnets for gold, silver and crude oil.

The author behind Viking Analytics has over twenty five years of experience as a financial analyst, business developer and commodity trader. In 2006, he founded a commodity recycling business, which he helped to grow to $20 million in revenues. After the business was sold in 2015, he has consulted for clients in the areas of finance, business development, and alternative investments. He loves to follow and study the financial markets and has become a believer in sound money.

Nick Po 3 years ago at 11:13 AM
The abuse of the retail customer in the silver and gold over the past many years has been well documented. It's way past time for the CME (and really government agencies) to take strong action to prevent this piracy. The limits should be on shorts. Some general ideas are: 1) limits on how much any one entity can have short unless they are a producer; 2) limits on total amount one can short in defined, low volume periods. Clearly, such unethical market manipulation is tolerated because it's backed by BIG money. However if you screw people long enough, they will revolt (e.g., take their business elsewhere) - and if all the retail customers go elsewhere, there's little incentive for BIG money to stay as there's no one left to manipulate. Goodbye CME.

Back to top